"This too is true -- stories can save us." Tim O'Brien, The Things They Carried
Friday, March 11, 2022
Boo
Sunday, March 6, 2022
The Transformation of Maria
When I was a child, I used to get strep throat a lot. As soon as the strep cleared, I basically contracted it right over again, and so the procedure of fever, doctor, diagnosis, crash on the couch for a few days became normal. I wasn't one of those kids who was psyched to miss school -- I loved school and had to be convinced to stay home on these contagious days. My mother sated me by renting a movie of my choice to watch while she went to work and my brothers went to school. The movie I asked for over and over and over was West Side Story. I'd been raised on the cannon of musicals -- Fiddler on the Roof, The Music Man, Oklahoma!, Phantom of the Opera, Gypsy, Annie, The Sound of Music, and more -- and I loved them all. But West Side Story spoke to my soul -- it was far and away my favorite. It's a long movie -- two and a half hours -- but I watched it over and over, especially once my mother caved and bought a copy so she wouldn't have to keep renting it. I knew every line of dialogue, every lyric of every song, and could mimic most of the dance moves. I had a white nightgown with a fanciful red sash that I would wear, even though Maria wasn't the character I wanted to emulate. It was fiery, passionate, witty, strong Anita that incurred all my love. I wanted to be Anita, even though I wasn't drawn to Bernardo, preferring the Jets' leader Riff for a leading man. For all my deep love of the movie, I wanted to mix everything up: the Jets were clearly the better gang to be in because, well, Riff, and also when you're a Jet you're a Jet all the way -- there was brotherhood, togetherness, support. Maybe the Sharks were like that offscreen, but they didn't have any songs telling me so. Meanwhile, the women who dated these Sharks were clearly superior to the passive arm candy women who hung around with the Jets. Jets boys, Sharks girls. That's the way I favored it.
But maybe I'm doing one better than that dream, since Anita became a role model for me beyond the context of West Side Story. She represents many pieces of me that are in play today.
I had the exceptional opportunity to watch this favorite movie of mine at the Somerville Theatre in Davis Square just last night and the experience was just beyond all expectations. My friend Shira came with me, which is always a delight, but as the movie began -- as the overture played -- I suddenly felt very emotional, like my childhood was about to be projected onto the big screen. That my dream of the past was going to play out in my present and shine a light into my future. The opening shot, panning over New York City while a call and response of whistles echoes over the vastness of the place, shook me up. I laid my head on Shira's shoulder and I said, "I'm so glad you're here." Shira, who just gets me, smiled. "I'm glad I'm here, too," she said.
Here is Maria, in her coming of age moment. You may recall that the first scene she's in, she's begging Anita to do something provocative with the white dress she's to wear to the dance. Couldn't Anita lower the neckline or at least dye it red? And here we are, in the final scene, with Maria finally in that red dress she longed for at the start. It's an incredibly powerful scene. Incredibly powerful. I was afraid to turn my head or blink or move in any way for fear I might crumble straight away. Maria, whose name means bitter. Maria in the red dress, mourning and in pain, surrounded by stunned and heavy silence. As the screen flashed "THE END," the packed house at the Somerville Theatre let out a breath it had been collectively holding. But otherwise, no one moved. No one. Not until "Music by Leonard Bernstein and Lyrics by Stephen Sondheim" flashed on the screen. Then everyone applauded and I began to breath normally again. I looked over at Shira who was looking back at me. God, I was relieved to be sitting next to a person that I love in that moment.
But that final scene also reminded me of the last time I watched West Side Story in the company of people I loved. It was May 2006 and there are lots of reasons why I know that. The main one is that I wrote a poem about the experience and I always date my poems. But I also know where I was in my own personal evolution -- it was an internal changing of the guard. I was just getting over true love, right as I was becoming close friends with a boy named Tom who played in a cover band my friend Whitney and I liked to go see. Whitney had a crush on Tom and that's sort of why we got into the habit of emailing with him during the week and it's how I got the idea to ask him to help me with a computer problem and it's what made him suggest we make a night out of it, including Whitney, and the two of them came to my first Somerville apartment on Sanborne Avenue in Union Square where Tom fixed my computer, introducing himself to my two roommates as "Tommy," which made Whitney and me giggle since we knew him as Tom and always had (later I would learn it was more common -- if not standard practice -- for him to introduce himself in the diminutive form of his name), and once my computer was fixed, we got some food and a bottle of Southern Comfort and we sat down to talk. There was a picture of me with my recently lost love on display and Tom asked some questions and when I lamented the end of that road, Tom said, "Any man who has even had the chance to touch you is the luckiest man," something I found very sweet, though it raised the eyebrows on, well, everyone I told after the fact, especially since Whitney, who very publicly was into Tom, was sitting right next to him on the couch. I just thought he was being kind. A lot of other people thought he was falling in love. I mean, it was over ten years ago -- who knows? But that night, Tom was definitely trying to duck and dodge Whitney's crush (a confusing thing since he'd very recently participated in a photo school project of hers that lead to them taking -- very tasteful and frankly pretty awesome -- pictures in the shower together, which made Whitney wonder if theirs was a path leading somewhere), and, at the same time, reaffirm the many similarities he and I shared, including some of our favorite movies. "You've never seen Mallrats?" Tom scoffed at Whitney as he pulled the DVD off my shelf and we put it right in the player. And when that film ended a little after midnight, we returned to an earlier discussion we'd had about both Tom and my favorite musical West Side Story, another movie Whitney had never seen, and despite the late hour, Tom and I rushed to put it on. Whitney loved the Leonardo DiCaprio Romeo and Juliet, so she simply had to see this classic update of that Shakespearean play. As the overture played, Tom warned us: "I always cry at the end," he said. Sure, sure, I remember thinking. But two hours and thirty minutes later, hand on a Bible, Tom was streaming tears down his face during Maria's final speech. It was hard not to think of this endearing and beautiful memory I have of Tom while watching West Side Story last night. It was hard not to have Maria's declaration of "Now I have hate, too," turn up the volume in my capacity to feel.
I don't hate Tom, I never could. But the pain resonating in Maria's outburst -- that I understood better than I ever have before.
West Side Story is personal for me -- it's part of me. Its existence in my life contributes to all that defines me as a human. I love it with my whole heart, my whole mind, my whole being. I'm still tingling from what I experienced last night and I will likely have more thoughts on the subject later. But I couldn't wait to share with you what I had so far.
I'll leave you with the poem I wrote on May 2, 2006 about another mile-marker moment in my life facilitated by the magic of my favorite movie:
Sunday, January 9, 2022
Wasted Time
She wasn’t much of a clean freak, that was for sure. Sitting on her tapestry-draped couch with her thin legs crossed high at the thighs, she leaned heavily on her elbows as she stared methodically at her perfectly manicured nails. She ignored the dust circling through the air and landing unceremoniously on her celebrity-magazine covered coffee table as well as the beeping of the coffeemaker in the kitchen alerting her that her brew was ready and had actually been ready for quite some time. She wasn’t sure she’d be drinking it, not alone at least.
If her eyes had not fixed themselves so obsessively on her maroon colored nails, they might have traveled to the closed door that separated her from the rest of the world. Someone was to have knocked on that door some time ago but she’d all but resigned herself to fixating on the next worldly problem – when would the first chip occur in her polish and how long after that until there were more and how long after that until she’d have to give in on this round and remove what was left so she could start all over again.
There was no knock, after all. What else should she be thinking about on this warm afternoon in the thick of a New England fall? The changing of the leaves or the adding of layers of clothes with each progressing day? Should she allow her mind to skip ahead to winter when she’d walk with her face turned down towards the ground to avoid the glare of the harsh sun against the relentless white of snow? No, it made more sense to stay grounded here, on her couch, with her legs pressed tightly together, her straight blonde hair hanging at attention just past her shoulders.
Sooner or later, though, the light outside wouldn’t be enough to sustain her and she’d have to move and when she would, her eyes would drift anywhere but towards that unanswerable door. To the box in the open hall closet that was intended to be a gracious means of transportation for his belongings to wherever he’d like those belongings to reside now that it wasn’t with her. If she let herself, she would imagine exactly what could fit in that box, maybe even things he hadn’t left behind, but things that were important to them – backstage passes to The Black Keys won on a radio show, a trophy from their kickball team, faded photos of them pressed together at places like beaches or reunions or ski slopes. If that empty box was packed just so, it would contain everything he would need to remember what he was losing and she’d be rid of it without regret.
Theirs was a breakup of her design. You’ll have to leave now, she’d said softly with clear eye contact. It had been weeks since the whole thing happened right here in this room, sitting side-by-side, dulled and silent. His eyes had widened for a moment before he swallowed hard and said, But I can help you. She had stood up and walked to the door. Opening it, she had said, I can help myself. After he had disappeared through this portal to the outside world, she’d felt her entire being light up like a golden flame and that is how she knew she had done the right thing.
They met when he stopped her in the middle of a park in the suburb of Boston where she’d grown up and asked her where she’d found the blue flower stuck behind her ear. She’d smiled at him and something zipped close inside her, something snug and comforting and warm. This was a good man who would love her – she knew it right away and he figured it out soon enough.
If only he was free to love her -- that was the only setback.
And technically, he was. His wife knew she wasn't the only one and so he never apologized for nights they spent apart. His capacity to love was greater than average -- and wife or not, she felt fulfilled of the promise he'd made that first night together -- I will be here for you, anything you need, any time at all. And it was all she needed for a long time. Their time together was precious, not wasted. Not wasted, that is, until a holiday rolled around or his birthday -- then she realized their time was borrowed, shared, not their own. Her friends avoided direct eye contact with her when she'd talk about him, good things and bad. They wanted more for her and she could feel that want in her gut more and more each withering day.
Then one morning and she woke up and realized she couldn’t get out of bed. The sheer weight of life pressed down upon her as he zipped up his jeans and threw on a t-shirt to go on with his day without her. He said he'd be back and he would but her eyes unfocused and she lost track of time. She half-slept with her mouth open and stared at the dust circling through the air.
For days she barely moved, barely spoke, refused all contact with the outside world -- even when he used his key to come in and spoon beside her in bed and talk about his day and try to coax her to have a story of her own. She could feel his concern but she could feel him being too late. And when she finally was able to sit up straight and stare at her long-since neglected nails, she knew what had to be done. First, she needed to stand on her own two feet. Second, she needed to move her two feet out of this sad room. And third, she needed to take care of her nails. She felt a certain thrill leaving the apartment and heading towards the nail salon two blocks over. She felt a certain thrill knowing that he’d come to see her and find her gone. Her mind raced with the conclusions he might draw. He’d never guess she’d gone out get her nails done. And the whole time she was at the salon, she thought and thought and thought about what had kept her trapped in bed for so long, what had prevented her from listening to his attempts to rally her, what had locked her down and by the time her nails were completely dried, her eyes widened for a moment before she closed them.
She needed her life back. There. That was it. She got up and left the salon and walked triumphantly through the door to find their shared space empty. Her shoulders sagged as her intended effect was lost when he showed up behind her moments later and she’d flinched when he’d touched her on the arm. We need to talk, she said.
After he was gone, she’d swept her arms around life and let it seep into her with abandon. Men came home with her whenever she asked them to and she imagined the one she’d sent away standing in the corner, watching her as she sprawled with these new suitors on the couch or curled intimately with them in her feather bed. She could almost still feel his arms around her in the shower and she could nearly feel his breath kiss her face as the mornings dawned. She’d watch these new men drink from his favorite coffee cups and stare at paintings he’d selected and it caused a thrilling flash through her to see these men-who-weren’t-him take these things in without knowing a thing about their history. They didn’t realize they were in a haunted house and she was in no hurry to tell them, either.
She was never in a hurry about anything, it seemed. She felt warm and content sitting on her couch as the dust swirled around her and the polish on her nails remained intact. Maybe that knock on the door would never come. No matter. It was all just wasted time.
This short story was written in 2013
Based on the Anomopoly song "Wasted Time"
Thursday, December 9, 2021
E is for Enchiladas
"If God dwells inside us like some people say He does,
I hope He likes enchiladas because that's what he's getting."
~ Deep Thoughts by Jack Handey
I.
I've only ever been impressed by one car in my entire life and it was a Cadillac Escalade. My best friend from college, Corey, and her fiance-at-the-time, Mike, had rented a pair of white ones for their wedding party to drive around in on the wedding day. She picked me up from the airport in one and I felt genuinely gorgeous in the posh, elevated, extravagant, unnecessarily over-the-top sensation of being in this super rad vehicle. That whole weekend, man. It was one of the best of my life. Getting picked up from the airport in an Escalade was just the start of unforgettable, wonderful experiences.
II.
True story: my younger brother Josh once fell into the Euphrates River. The Euphrates, as you may or may not be aware, is a major waterway in Western Asia. It is also extremely polluted. My brother took a tumble into the water, much to the chagrin of the people he was with, and a delicate cleanup procedure had to be implemented. I can only imagine the whole scene -- my brother is extremely tall and very friendly and Mid-Western. How could anyone get angry at this lovable giant? They couldn't! But grumpy -- they could definitely be grumpy. And the cleanup? It was a success.
III.
Once for Tom's birthday, I gave him a DVD of the movie Stepbrothers. I thought he'd think it was funny. I gave it to him at a trivia night at The Druid in Inman Square, handing it over in a felt gift bag shaped like a ladybug, a symbol that is of extreme importance to me. The bag had handles that Tom looped around his wrist like a handbag, clutching the gift to his chest for the rest of the evening as we played trivia with our friends and drank beer and whiskey and it's one of the most endearing memories I have of him.
IV.
On my flight to Ohio this Christmas, there was a girl a few rows behind me who cried -- moaned -- for the last thirty minutes of this seventy-five minute flight. She was maybe eight and only slightly eclipsed by the two-year-old who sat directly behind me kicking my seat with great gusto for the entire seventy-five minutes while he parents cheered at a football game they were watching. Near the end of the flight, as the girl's moaning increased, so did her mother's frustration as she said through audibly gritted teeth, "Have a DRINK, Margot." Have a drink, Margot. We all wanted a drink, Margot. And we all got one as soon as the plane landed and we dispersed to our final destinations.
V.
I knew God was real when I was eight-years-old. I was kneeling in church during a Maundy Thursday service. Maundy Thursday is part of the Christian Easter holiday -- it's "Good Friday Eve," the day celebrating The Last Supper and other events leading up to Jesus' crucifixion. During the service, the altar is stripped of everything -- the ceremony is very moving. And the first time I ever experienced it, the minister, George Ross, had the church lights dimmed and the most poignant organ music playing. I was in the choir so I was so close to it all. There were no words spoken -- only actions -- only movement -- only event. It was the most beautiful thing I have ever experienced in my life. I knew right then, without explanation or need for one, that God was part of this human experience, and it filled me with the most powerful form of love.
Christmas Song
Come they told me, pa rum pum pum pum
A newborn king to see, pa rum pum pum pum
Our finest gifts we bring, pa rum pum pum pum
To lay before the king, pa rum pum pum pum
So to honor him, pa rum pum pum pum
When we come
It was three days before Christmas and their parents had left them home alone. It wasn’t unusual – this brother and sister dynamic duo had braved long hours solo before and they weren’t afraid. If anything, they were excited to see their parents blow air kisses in their direction as they whisked out the door. This would give the children time to look for their presents, since the elder sister had finally broken it to the younger brother that Santa Claus wasn’t real.
“Mom and Dad hide the presents in the attic,” the sister said as she turned the carols up on the stereo. “When they leave, we’ll look up there.”
The brother was still feeling dizzy from the realization that his entire childhood had been a lie up until this point. He only half-trusted his sister as it was and he wasn’t certain she was right about this news, except that he’d asked around at school and everyone else in the second grade seemed to be privy to the same information as she was.
“Dummy, you still believe in Santa?” one of the boys chided. “Dummy.”
He wanted to retort that his sister was in the fifth grade and she’d only known for a year and a half but he didn’t bother. Details like that were unimportant in a cafeteria powwow like this one.
He felt similarly powerless when his sister turned, eyes gleaming, towards him and said, “Good, they’re gone, let’s get up there.”
She was afraid of nothing, not the dark, not thunderstorms, not even spiders. He was afraid of all of those things and they seemed to be converging on him in this moment as rain began to pelt the window with a ripe roll of thunder ripped across the lower register while his sister grabbed him by the hand, pulling him down the dark hallway to the door leading up to the cobwebby attic. Standing outside, she rubbed her hands together with determination and turned the handle. Downstairs, “Angels We Have Heard On High” blared from the speakers.
“Shit,” she said.
The attic door was predictably locked. Their parents had a strict rule about the children not playing up there and they knew it, but for some reason, the sister had blocked that out of her mind – or perhaps she thought her sheer force of determination to get up there would burst open any locks standing in her way. The brother stood meekly beside her, partially relieved at this expected turn of events but also worried because he was certain his sister wouldn’t give up so easily.
“Let’s play hide and seek,” she said slowly.
“It’s too dark,” he said.
“Nonsense,” she said. “You go hide and I’ll seek, OK?”
He turned begrudgingly away from her and moved in a slow trot downstairs where there were at least some lights on, leaving his sister to mull over her options in the dark. The sister stared at the locked door for a moment tapping her finger against her lip and then turned quickly on her heels into her parents’ room. Her mother had a jewelry box in the top dresser drawer that she was specifically forbidden to touch because of the valuables it contained. The sister knew, in her heart, that this is where she’d find the key.
Downstairs, the brother crouched on the cool kitchen floor behind the island their father installed himself that summer and waited for his sister to come and find him. Outside, the rain had picked up and was steadily pelting the kitchen window. Every time the thunder clapped, he shook a little more, wrapping his arms tightly around his knees. Not even Bing Crosby singing “Silent Night” could assuage his fears. Where was she already, he wondered. Finally, he got up and peeked around the island to see if she was doing that creepy thing she liked to do and stare at him from the staircase. But she wasn’t there. Moving slowly, he crawled back up the stairs to the hallway where he’d left her.
“Sis?” he called when she didn’t immediately appear, exasperated that he wasn’t hiding like he was supposed to.
Outside, the wind howled and roared as the rain turned to sleet and pelted the windows. Otherwise, things were still and silent. He crept slowly down the empty hallway back to the attic door and instinctively turned the knob. It opened effortlessly. Blinking in confusion, he rocked weight between his feet and tried again.
“Sis?” he called.
The wind sounded so much louder from the bottom of that enclosed stairwell. He could hear nothing but the storm – the carols were shut out and replaced by this terrible phase of winter coming inside his home. He was drawn forward, up the stairs, one by one, and when he reached the top, he felt an awful chill as his eyes fixed on a window likely broken by a wayward tree branch, floorboards warping even more than was typical. The old white velvet Christmas tree skirt with the red wine stains lay over a wooden chest and he moved towards it, getting his socks wet as he went along. Their mother had bought a new tree skirt this year – a cotton one that wasn’t anything fancy but it also wasn’t the one her now-dead mother had given them.
“Grandma won’t mind a change in tradition,” their mother had said as the children protested the change. “Out with the old, et cetera, et cetera.”
“Ow,” the brother said as his foot rocked over something sharp. He looked down with worried eyes as a tiny spot of blood seeped out through his white sock.
“Be careful,” his sister hissed in his ear, appearing out of nowhere.
He jumped and stumbled away from her, sliding on the floor. “I stepped on glass,” he said.
“I see,” the sister mused.
“How’d you unlock the door?” he asked.
“Found the key in Mom’s jewelry box,” she said. ”Our presents are over in the corner.”
The brother followed the direction of her gesture and sat up a little taller. “Anything good?”
“Everything we asked for,” she said with a shrug. Reaching over, she helped him to his feet. “Let’s go take a look at your foot,” she added.
The brother stood still. “I want to see,” he said.
“Why?” she asked. “You’re bleeding all over.”
They both shivered as the wind and rain blew towards them.
“Did I get a drum set?” he asked hopefully.
“You’ll have to wait and be surprised,” she said with her tongue sticking out.
He balled his fists and pursed his lips together. “I’ll just come up here by myself and look,” he sputtered.
“No you won’t, you chicken,” she laughed. “You’d never come up here unless you were under adult supervision.”
“You’re not an adult,” he said.
“I’m not afraid,” she retorted.
“You got to look,” he said. “You tricked me and made me go hide while you came to see what we were getting for Christmas.”
The sister shrugged. “I knew you’d have, ya know, moral qualms about digging through Mom’s stuff to find the key.”
“You know I’m afraid of thunderstorms,” the brother went on, his lips quivering. “You know I hate the dark. But you left me alone anyway.”
“I didn’t leave you in the dark,” the sister said.
“I want to see,” the brother said again.
“After we clean up your foot,” the sister said, taking his arm.
“No,” the brother said, jerking backwards and losing his balance.
It was as if life was suddenly in slow motion. The brother took a poorly planned step back in an attempt to right himself but instead he slipped over the edge of the staircase and fell backwards down the steps in a percussive tumble. The sister stood stock still, her hands frozen in midair with her eyes fixated on the trail of blood he’d left behind.
Years later, the sister sat in yet another therapist’s office gripping the edge of an Italian leather chair telling the story of the day the brother became paralyzed. It was all my fault, she said for the hundredth time. I was so close, I could have saved him, I could have stopped it, I could have made sure none of it happened at all. She paused as she always did in the retelling. “Little Drummer Boy” was on the stereo while I dialed 9-1-1. I cry every time I hear that song. Sometimes I turn it on in the dark during thunderstorms and just cry and cry. Maybe that sounds crazy, doc, but that’s the magic of Christmas to me. As she paused, the therapist sat blank faced and waited for her to go on.
"Christmas Song" was written in 2013
Inspired by "Christmas Song" by Anomopoly