Awoken by banging at the door, terror moved through my body. From the kitchen, I heard a tea cup clank and hit the floor. For just a moment, a smile flit across my face, knowing that my cat Rufus was just as startled by the unexpected guest as I was. I got up slowly and slid my feet into my slippers, just in case I had to run outside.
The banging persisted.
Rufus darted past me in the hallway, certainly going to hide in the darkest corner he could find.
My heart thubbed in my throat as I tried to swallow. The acrid taste of adrenaline made me wretch as the thunderous banging erupted once more. I tiptoed across the creaky old hardwood floors in my apartment's living room and came to stillness a foot away from the door. It was hard to detect a shadow from under the doorway -- which only meant that whoever was in the hallway wouldn't necessarily know I was right there on the other side. I winced, remembering that I'd left my cellphone on the table by my bed. I wondered if I should go and get it before I investigated further.
But the banging. It was getting more frantic. I moved my mouth in a silent who's there as I almost robotically made my way to look through the peephole.
I instinctively gasped. A loud gasp. A there's-no-way-no-one-heard-that gasp.
The banging in the hallway stopped.
"Claire?" asked the familiar voice.
I took in a deep breath and exhaled. "Hold on, Jeff," I said, now moving as if I were in a dream. Slowly, I opened the door wide. I stood firmly on the welcome mat just inside the door and I stared at him. He looked unwashed and he smelled it too. That pungent blend of beer and piss and sweat that I'd gotten so used to over the last five years especially.
"Hey, sis," he said, his voice sweet and steady, even though his eyes looked nervous as they darted around. "Can I come in?"
I didn't move. "Do you know what time it is?" I asked.
Jeff started to fidget. "No, I lost my phone and I..."
I held up my hand for him to stop. "Is it dark outside?" I asked.
"Yeah," he said.
"Has it been dark for a few hours?" I asked.
"Yeah," he said, his gaze dropping to the ground.
"So do you think you could guess within a two hour range of It's-the-Fucking-Middle-of-the-Night?" I asked.
Jeff scratched his head, his eyes still fixed on the floor. "Probably."
"Definitely," I corrected him. "What do you want."
"Can I come in?" he asked again, lifting his gaze back up to meet mine.
"I won't give you any money and you can't stay the night here," I said.
"Deal," Jeff said, the drill now more familiar than either of us cared to admit.
I moved my body out of the way and he moved swiftly past me, almost if he thought I might change my mind in that split second. I watched him go immediately into the kitchen to sit on one of the wooden chairs at the table. He knew I didn't want him to sit on my couch or any chairs covered with cloth -- he knew I didn't want him to soak his stink into my home that way.
Without asking, I started to brew some coffee and then opened the refrigerator to see what I could offer him.
"Leftover pizza OK?" I asked, not really caring if he wanted something else.
"Sure. Thanks," he said as I handed him the ziplock bag with three generously sized slices. "What's this?" he added, looking at the floor where the pieces of the broken teacup remained.
"You scared Rufus with your banging," I said dryly as I watched my brother take the pizza slices out of the bag, set them on a paper plate, and put them in the microwave.
"Where's the pizza from?" Jeff asked.
"Satan's Butthole," I quipped. "What, are we making small talk now?"
Jeff's shoulders sagged as we both seemed to count down the minute he had set to warm up the pizza. When the timer went off, he pulled the plate out and sat back down on the chair. I watched him eat with a blend of pity and disgust. Knowing him, it could have been days since he'd had anything besides booze in his system. I turned my attention to the coffee that had now brewed enough I could pour us each a cup. We both took it black -- just like our father had taught us.
"Where are you staying?" I asked, sliding the mug over to him.
"With Ben and Marie," he said so quickly I knew he was lying.
I let him lie. "How's their new puppy?" I asked.
"What, are we making small talk?" Jeff snapped back before catching himself. "It's cute," he said. "They named it Wrinkles."
I sipped my coffee and sighed. "Why are you here?" I asked.
"Can't a guy just want to come see his sister?" he asked.
"Sure," I said. "But usually, that doesn't mean banging on the door in the middle of the night. Usually it might mean sending a message ahead of time to see what time is good and that sort of thing. You do recall some of the rules of society, right?"
It was Jeff's turn to sigh. "Look, I fucked up again. I needed to get off the street. I didn't have my phone. Your buzzer has been broken for months --"
"It got fixed last week," I inserted.
Jeff's mouth hung open before he continued. "Well, I didn't know that. I just knew that if I wanted to get into your apartment, I'd have to bang on the door. So I banged on the door."
"What do you mean you 'fucked up'?" I asked. "Details. And don't lie."
A strange shadow flickered over Jeff's face. "I tried to rob the dry cleaners, over on Cutter Street," he said.
"Tried?" I repeated.
He nodded grimly. "I was loaded when I went in there and I had this fake gun I swiped from someone at the bar last week. I went in there right before closing because I know they usually only have one person on at closing and so I thought it would be easy." He paused a rubbed his hand across his brow. "Mallory Jennings was working," he said finally.
I felt my breath catch. At this time five years ago, Mallory Jennings was almost going to be my sister-in-law. I waited for Jeff to continue.
"I didn't even know she was back in town, let alone working at the fucking dry cleaners," he said after a moment as he put his hand over his eyes, almost as if to block out the memory. "I went in there, pointing the fake gun and yelling for the cash and I didn't even realize it was her at first..." Jeff's voice trailed off.
I watched his face contort in this very specific way that can only be described as sorrow and regret and pain all spiraled into one broken spirit.
"I was just yelling for her to give me the money and she said, 'Jeff, is that you?'" He paused. "Claire, when I tell you that I almost threw up when I heard her say my name..."
I felt the grip around my coffee cup tighten. "Did you?"
"Did I what?" Jeff asked.
"Throw up," I prodded.
"No," Jeff said.
"Are you going to now because you're looking queasy," I said, knowing the telltale signs all too well.
Jeff got up and poured himself a glass of water. "I'm fine," he said, his bloodshot eyes trying to focus on me.
"Yeah, clearly," I said through gritted teeth. "So then what happened," I prompted.
"Right, so, I wasn't wearing a mask or disguise or anything so, yeah, she knew who I was and saw me pointing this gun at her -- I mean, fake gun but maybe she didn't know it was fake -- and screaming to give me all the money... What else could I do but get the fuck out of there?" he asked.
I nodded slowly. "Do you think she called the cops?" I asked.
He shrugged. "Knowing Mal, probably not," he said.
My mind pulled me back through the wormhole to what my brother's life was like around the time that Mallory had left him, just one month before their wedding. They were fresh-faced and right out of college, on the cusp of new careers and an exciting beginning -- or at least that's how it appeared to all of us.
None of us knew that Mallory had become a regular heroin user and that she'd addicted Jeff along the way. None of us knew that she'd nearly overdosed twice in the year since their engagement and that Jeff had had to perform life-saving CPR on her. None of us knew anything about how their addictions had crippled them, financially, emotionally, spiritually.
Not until Mallory called off the engagement and checked in to a private rehab facility that her parents helped her find.
I still remember how shocked I was to find out that my big brother, this person I'd idolized since I was a toddler, was living this whole other life that I knew nothing about. And while Mallory took steps to get clean and start over, my brother just continued to spiral out. He'd tried rehab once and quit at the end of the first week. He'd tried AA and other support-type groups but it hadn't been enough to give him the strength he needed to kick the habit. I'd spent the last five years watching my once-hero, former star athlete, academic over-achiever of a brother turn into this gnarled, dirty, animalistic version of himself.
I could sit here in the same room with him and have a steel look on my face.
But inside, I was hurt. I was scared. I was lost. All I wanted was for my brother to come back. Sometimes on clearer days, I'd search his eyes to see if my brother was even still in there somewhere. Then I'd cry myself to sleep that night, broken hearted that he just wasn't.
Our family had gone through so many transformations since Mallory's decision to break the engagement unearthed all of these secrets. I felt so foolish that I hadn't known, hadn't detected anything was wrong. I spent all this time with them and I even partied with them sometimes and I still didn't know. I never thought anything of it when they'd ask to borrow a few bucks here or there -- and even when a "few bucks" increased in value as it got closer to their breakup, I just assumed it was because the wedding was a stress on their funds.
I will never forgive myself that I didn't know.
Looking at my brother now, I wondered if I could have prevented this.
"OK, so when exactly did this robbery attempt take place?" I asked, pulling myself back into the present.
Jeff scratched at his chin. "Maybe 6pm? Whenever they closed," he said.
"What have you been doing since 6pm?" I asked.
Jeff shrugged. "I went over to park for awhile," he said, referencing a neighborhood spot where we both knew he liked to hide back in a spot with a picnic table surrounded by a lot of trees. "I didn't hear any sirens or anything, so then I went to the bar," he added.
"Then after last call you had nowhere to go so you came here," I concluded for him.
Jeff offered a tiny shrug. "Something like that," he said.
I stood up. "When I ask you to leave in five minutes, where will you go," I asked.
Jeff swallowed hard. "I told you, I'm staying with Ben and Marie," he said.
I thought about calling him on his lie but determined there was no use. "If you want to use my shower, you can. I have a fresh set of your clothes in the bag in the hall closet where the towels are. After you shower, you will have to leave," I said.
A light of gratitude flashed in my brother's eyes. "Thanks, sis," he said softly as he walked past me, down the hall to my bathroom. A minute or so later, I heard the water turn on.
Still sitting at the kitchen table, my head fell into my hands and I sobbed. I sobbed for what I'd lost -- for what Jeff had lost -- for what our family had lost. I'd give anything to be back to being the naïve kid who thought her brother was a super hero. I'd give anything not to have to be the kind of sister who'd tell her brother he wasn't welcome in her home.
I'd give anything not to be the human who'd learned in the hardest possible way that compassion comes with boundaries. I couldn't let him stay.
My eyes were red and puffy by the time the water shut off in my shower and a few minutes after that, Jeff was standing in the kitchen doorway looking more like the version of my brother my memory always wanted to return to.
"Thanks, Claire, you're a good sister," he said.
"See ya around," I said, my voice thick with emotion I so often had to hide from him.
"See ya around," he said, walking down the hall and out my door.
I sat in the kitchen staring at the pieces of the broken teacup still scattered on the floor. I left them there and went back to bed.
First line by Holly Disch
Virtual Tip Jar: Venmo @sarahwolfstar.